PRESS STATEMENT | Home Affairs ordered to unblock IDs of LHR clients in 20 days

Date: 20/09/2024


In a significant legal victory for Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) and vulnerable individuals across South Africa, the Pretoria High Court has once again ordered the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) to unblock the identity documents (IDs) of 142 LHR clients within 20 days. This ruling underscores the broader impact on thousands of individuals suffering under the same flawed administrative system. The judgment, handed down by Judge Van der Schyff in the matter of Phindile Philile Mazibuko and Others v Minister of Home Affairs and Others, follows months of non-compliance by the DHA with a previous court order in the Mazibuko case, issued in January 2024.

Since January 2024, when the court handed down the original judgment in the Mazibuko case, the DHA has failed to comply fully with orders to investigate and unblock the IDs of hundreds of individuals effectively stripping them of their constitutional rights and dignity. Many have been left unable to access essential services, work, or conduct basic transactions since their IDs were blocked. The January judgment confirmed that the DHA’s actions were unconstitutional, but despite this, the Department failed to fully comply with the court’s directions.

The ruling on 18 September 2024 came after LHR was forced to return to court following the DHA’s continued non-compliance with the Mazibuko order. While the court did not find the DHA in contempt, it confirmed that the Department had failed to unblock IDs by the deadline. Judge Van der Schyff ordered that the unblocking must now be completed within 20 days, and must be treated as if it had been done by 25 June 2024.

Further, the court addressed a crucial issue of inconsistency: the DHA claimed to have unblocked some IDs as early as July 2024, but the numbers kept changing, causing confusion and concern. As a result, the court has demanded an affidavit from the DHA, due by 27 September, explaining exactly which IDs have been unblocked and when.

In a parallel development, the DHA published a Notice on 16 August 2024, threatening to cancel IDs unless affected individuals submitted written representations within 30 days. While Judge Van der Schyff ruled that this Notice does not apply to LHR’s clients, the Notice remains a looming threat for thousands of others, who could lose their IDs altogether without a fair administrative process.

This case is not just about LHR’s clients—it’s about the thousands of individuals whose rights are being violated by arbitrary and unconstitutional actions. The failure to unblock IDs impacts the most vulnerable members of our society, exacerbating poverty, inequality, and exclusion.

LHR calls on the DHA to urgently comply with the court’s order and to address the broader crisis by reviewing and reforming its administrative processes. The thousands of individuals facing the threat of having their IDs cancelled under the DHA’s recent directive must be afforded fairness and proper administrative processes. A just and transparent system is essential to ensure that no one’s rights are violated, and that every individual can access justice and their basic constitutional rights

For more information, please contact:

Sihle Nyangiwe

Attorney, Lawyers for Human Rights

Tel: 031 301 0531

Thank you for joining
Thank you for joining the LHR Newsletter, we will be in touch soon